Now that Halloween is very safely over (and I have pretty much recovered).. I will tell you how ours went this year.
I had the great idea, very late into the game, that I would make costumes for everyone. Everyone. Lily finally decided that she wanted to be Fionna (from Adventure Time). Originally she was telling me she wanted to dress up as costumes she already had (strawberry, cowgirl on a horse, etc) until I thoroughly explained that she could be anything she wanted.. and I would make her costume for her.
So, she decided on Raven from Teen Titans Go. Which I was thrilled about. Cape- easy to make. I could buy a black long-sleeved mock-turtle leotard, some beige/tan leggings, and short black boots. Add in a few small details and it would be done. Then she changed her mind.
Thankfully I hadn't purchased anything for a Raven costume yet. I asked her over and over and over what she wanted to be for about a week just to make sure she was still saying "Fionna".. and I began the costume assemblage.
She already had three shirts that she could choose from so I figured I'd just buy a blue skirt, black shoes, blue striped tube socks, etc etc. Haha.
The perfect shoes were quickly found at Payless, but the skirt? I looked absolutely everywhere I could think of online for a blue skirt. There were a few possibilities, but "surprisingly" mid-October is not a good time for buying anything close to blue bicycle shorts for preschoolers. So... I made her a skirt.. with shorts attached underneath. I traced a pair of her leggings and improvised the rest.
I also designed and made her backpack, painted blue stripes on the tops of her knee socks (after the attempt with ribbon failed), and added yellow "hair" onto the hat we bought her. Jason and I repainted a foam sword for her.. and she was pretty much in heaven over all of it.
Noah on the other hand had absolutely no say in his costume. Just like last year, poor thing.
I had planned to create a Princess Bubblegum (from the same show) in her science gear costume for myself, but spent so much time on Lily and Noah's costumes that I knew I'd never even have a chance at half-completing it.. so I didn't even start. But, Noah's costume was more to match my own.. with his being Science, her candy corn mouse/rat lab assistant.
I partially used a pattern for his costume, but made a lot of changes to the basic lion/pig/whatever form. I also made a pair of pants to go under it and a hat with ears I knew he'd never wear.
Although time consuming, everything was fairly easy and came out really cute. Proof during our one "real" trick or treating stop after sort of bizarre mall trick or treating..
It was the only time that night Noah had his mouse ears hat on. Or would allow it I should say. All my pictures of him are either from the back or a blurred streak. Constant motion that one is. Really, both of them.
Next year I need to start earlier, because I'm not sure who was more disappointed that I was dressed up, me or Lily..